| Platinum | Joey's Seafood Restaurants - Thunder Bay |
| Gold | Joey's Restaurants |
| Silver |
The Sal
|
| Bronze | Daytona's |
| Bronze | Red Lion Smokehouse |
| Bronze | The Eddy Restaurant |
| Top Pick | 5 Forks Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Caribou Restaurant & Wine Bar |
| Top Pick | East Coast Lobster |
| Top Pick | Madhouse |
