| Platinum | Maltese Grocery |
| Gold | Superior Foods |
| Silver | The Commissary Deli & Smoked Meats |
| Bronze | Country Fresh Meats & Deli |
| Top Pick | Bay Meats Butcher Shop |
| Top Pick | Bogdala's Smoked Meat |
| Top Pick | European Meats & Deli |
| Top Pick | George's Market and Celebrations |
| Top Pick | North Country Meat Shop |
| Top Pick | Tim's Meats Deli & Grocery |