| Platinum | Salt & Pepper Catering |
| Gold | Pinetree Catering |
| Silver | Bay Village Coffee |
| Bronze | The Sal |
| Top Pick | Crock-N-Dial Sandwiches |
| Top Pick | Daytona's |
| Top Pick | Hot Paddle Pizza |
| Top Pick | Italian Cultural Centre |
| Top Pick | NYS Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Perogies By Maybellina |
| Top Pick | Sweet and Savoury Grazing Co. |