| Platinum | Epic Cones |
| Gold | The Countryside Cakery |
| Silver | Dolce Coffee House |
| Silver | Totally Toasted Marshmallows & S'More |
| Bronze | Mini Donut Shoppe |
| Bronze | Prime Gelato |
| Top Pick | Crumbs Bakery |
| Top Pick | Merla-Mae Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Rock It Chocolate |
| Top Pick | Sweet North Bakery |
| Top Pick | TJ's Ice Cream Shoppe |