| Platinum | Crumbs Bakery |
| Gold | Sweet North Bakery |
| Silver | Milk and Water |
| Bronze | Bay Village Coffee |
| Bronze | The Persian Man |
| Top Pick | Current River Bakery |
| Top Pick | Just Baked |
| Top Pick | Molly's Sweet Bakes |
| Top Pick | Nucci's Bake A Deli |
| Top Pick | She Can Cook Catering |