| Platinum | Tilted Turret Pinball Pub |
| Gold | The Shake Shoppe |
| Silver | Prospector Burger Barn |
| Bronze | Nippers Take Out |
| Top Pick | Beefcake Burger Factory |
| Top Pick | Carrie's Corner |
| Top Pick | Coney Island Westfort |
| Top Pick | New York Fries |
| Top Pick | Outlaws burgers and fries |
| Top Pick | The Sovereign Room |