| Platinum | Maltese Grocery |
| Gold | Pie.Ology |
| Silver | Bogdala's Smoked Meat |
| Bronze | Jennifer's Gluten-Free Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Fresco's Deli |
| Top Pick | House of Meredith Perogies |
| Top Pick | June & Jo Spice Co |
| Top Pick | Perogies By Maybellina |
| Top Pick | Shumka Dust |
| Top Pick | The Little Pie Shop |