| Platinum | Milk and Water |
| Platinum | The Countryside Cakery |
| Gold | Carol's Cakes |
| Silver | Dagwoods Bakery & Deli |
| Silver | GOTT cupcakes |
| Silver | Sprinkle & Spice |
| Bronze | Dolce Coffee House |
| Bronze | Nucci's Bake A Deli |
| Bronze | Witchy Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Club Cappuccino Cafe & Desserts |
| Top Pick | Holland Bakery |